Johanel Caraballo ha enfrentado a 42 oponentes a lo largo de su carrera.

Player Team(s) Games
Angel Alamo 1
Carlos Arroyo 2
Angel Ayala 1
Elias Ayuso 2
Reginald Becton 2
Miguel Ali Berdiel 2
Nathaniel Butler 1
Raymond Cintron 1
Coty Clarke 1
Denis Clemente 1
Devon Collier 1
Alexis Colon 2
David Cortes 1
Manuel De Jesus 1
Felix De Jesus 1
Cliff Duran 1
Philip Fournier 1
Ansel Guzman 1
Walter Hodge 1
David Huertas 1
Damion James 2
Davon Jefferson 1
David Laury 1
Will Martinez 1
Angel Matias 1
Ricardo Melendez 2
Steven Miro 2
Tony Mitchell 1
Ferdinand Morales 1
William Orozco 1
Chris Ortiz 2
Nathan Peavy 2
Emmanuel Pellot 1
Yudniel Perez 1
Filiberto Rivera 2
Jose Rodriguez 1
Christian Soto 1
Rasham Suarez 1
Edwin Ubiles 1
Florentino Valencia 1
Luis Villafane 2
Xavier Zambrana 2